Correction, October 27, 2026. We rewrote this article. An earlier version quoted three passages about advertising and attributed them to the State Bar’s 2023 generative AI guidance. The guidance contains no such passages; it doesn’t discuss marketing or the advertising rules at all. The earlier version also cited rule subsections that don’t exist (Rules 7.4(c) and 7.4(d)) and said California bars “specializing in” wording, which Rule 7.4(b) allows. We regret the errors. Everything below is checked against the guidance and the rule text, both linked at the end.
California’s 2023 guidance on generative AI is often cited in law-firm marketing as if it were an advertising rule. It isn’t. It explains how a lawyer’s existing duties apply when they use AI tools. What your marketing may say is still governed by Rules 7.1 through 7.5, and those rules apply the same way whether a person or an AI drafted the copy.
What the guidance is
The Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law was developed by the State Bar’s Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct. It runs five pages and is organized by duty:
| Duty | Rules cited | What it means for marketing work |
|---|---|---|
| Confidentiality | Bus. & Prof. Code § 6068(e); Rules 1.6, 1.8.2 | Don’t put confidential client information into AI tools without adequate confidentiality and security protections; anonymize it. In marketing, this comes up with case studies and testimonials. |
| Competence and diligence | Rules 1.1, 1.3 | Review and correct what AI produces. The lawyer’s judgment can’t be handed to the tool. That includes anything drafted in the firm’s name. |
| Complying with the law | Bus. & Prof. Code § 6068(a); Rules 8.4, 1.2.1 | Using AI doesn’t suspend other legal obligations. |
| Supervision | Rules 5.1, 5.2, 5.3 | Managerial lawyers should set clear policies on permitted AI uses and train people on them. Rule 5.3 covers nonlawyers who assist the firm. |
| Communication with clients | Rules 1.4, 1.2 | Consider telling clients when you plan to use AI on their matter. |
| Fees | Rule 1.5; Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 6147–6148 | Bill actual time spent; don’t charge hourly fees for time the AI saved. |
| Candor; meritorious claims | Rules 3.1, 3.3 | Check AI output before relying on it in a filing. |
| Discrimination, harassment, retaliation | Rule 8.4.1 | Watch for bias in AI tools. |
| Other jurisdictions | Rule 8.5 | Other jurisdictions’ rules may also apply. |
None of the nine sections mentions marketing, advertising, or Rules 7.1 to 7.5. For marketing, the useful parts are the general duties: review what the AI drafts, keep client information out of tools that can’t protect it, and set a policy for who may use which tools.
What actually governs your marketing copy
California’s advertising rules took effect on November 1, 2018, with the rest of the current Rules of Professional Conduct. They don’t distinguish AI-written copy from human-written copy. These are the parts AI drafts run into most often:
- The core rule. Rule 7.1(a): a lawyer shall not make a false or misleading communication about the lawyer or the lawyer’s services.
- Guarantees. Under Comment [2], a communication that contains an express guarantee or warranty of the result is false or misleading.
- “No fee without recovery.” Comment [3] treats this as misleading unless the communication also says whether the client will be liable for costs. The same comment covers true statements that mislead because they leave out needed facts.
- Results and testimonials. Comment [4]: past results, testimonials and endorsements can mislead by creating an unjustified expectation that other clients will get the same results. An appropriate disclaimer or qualifying language often avoids that.
- Other languages. Comment [5] covers communications that imply the firm can serve clients in a language other than English. Read it before an AI tool translates your pages.
- Specialization. Rule 7.4(a): a lawyer may not state or imply being a certified specialist unless currently certified by the State Bar’s Board of Legal Specialization or another entity the State Bar accredits, and the certifying organization is clearly identified. Rule 7.4(b): a lawyer may say the practice specializes in, is limited to, or is concentrated in a field, subject to Rule 7.1. So “our practice specializes in immigration law” is allowed if it’s true; “certified immigration specialist” needs the certification and the certifier’s name.
- Standards. Rule 7.1(b) lets the State Bar’s Board of Trustees adopt standards describing communications presumed to violate Rules 7.1 to 7.5. Check the current standards as part of any review.
Comparative claims such as “best” or “top” aren’t named in California’s rule text, but they fall under Rule 7.1: a comparison that can’t be backed up, or that misleads in context, is a problem. Some states spell this out more specifically; see our state-by-state comparison.
Where AI-drafted copy goes wrong
AI tools write in a confident, promotional voice by default. Check anything they draft for these six patterns before it publishes:
- Outcome promises: “we will win,” “you’ll get the compensation you deserve.”
- “No fee unless we win” without saying whether the client pays costs.
- Results or testimonials with no context or qualifying language.
- “Certified specialist,” “board-certified,” or other wording that implies a certification the lawyer doesn’t hold.
- “Best,” “top” or “leading” with nothing to support it.
- Translated pages that imply services the firm can’t provide in that language.
A workable review process
- Review every public piece before it publishes: practice pages, bios, FAQs, social posts and guest articles. Rule 7.1 covers all communications about the lawyer’s services, so short posts aren’t exempt.
- Have the reviewer fix problems, not just flag them, and keep a short log of what changed and who approved it.
- Keep client information out of AI tools unless their confidentiality protections are adequate, as the guidance advises.
- Write down which AI tools staff and outside vendors may use for marketing, in line with the guidance’s advice on AI-use policies.
This is a marketing-content screen, not legal advice. Your firm’s attorneys decide what publishes.
Sources
- State Bar of California, Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct).
- State Bar of California, Rules of Professional Conduct, Chapter 7: Information About Legal Services (Rules 7.1–7.6), effective November 1, 2018.
New to the topic? Start with the complete guide: GEO for Law Firms.
The foundation: AI search and ABA Model Rule 7.1. On the ABA’s own AI opinion: ABA Formal Opinion 512 and law-firm marketing. Outside California? See the state-by-state view.
About Legal Torch. Legal Torch is a generative engine optimization (GEO) agency that works only with law firms. We screen every public-facing deliverable against ABA Model Rule 7.1 and the firm’s state advertising rules before it publishes, and the firm’s attorney approves it. We measure AI visibility on each engine separately and never guarantee outcomes. See our GEO service and how the compliance review works.